In this video from "English with Lucy," the host challenges advanced English learners to find seven punctuation mistakes hidden within a short text about unusual food combinations [00:00], [01:35].
The Challenge Text
The video presents a paragraph discussing bizarre food pairs—such as pineapple on pizza, strawberries with balsamic vinegar, peanut butter and pickles, tomatoes with milk, and watermelon with feta cheese—which contains seven intentionally placed punctua
tion errors [00:31], [01:04], [01:35].
Detailed Breakdown of the Mistakes and Punctuation Rules
Mistake 1: The Incorrect Semicolon (Line 2)
Context: "...far stranger combinations exist semicolon and they work incredibly well" [03:06].
Correction: Remove the semicolon [03:18].
Explanation: Semicolons are used to join two related independent clauses without a coordinating conjunction (like and, but, or or) [03:39]. Using both a semicolon and a coordinating conjunction
is redundant [03:49].
Mistake 2: Missing Comma for a Non-Defining Relative Clause (Line 3)
Context: "...balsamic vinegar which enhances the fruit's natural sweetness" [04:24].
Correction: Add a comma before which [04:34].
Explanation: Which introduces a non-defining relative clause, which requires a preceding comma in writing to match a slight pause in speech [04:45].
Mistake 3: Missing Apostrophe for Possession (Line 3)
Context: "...enhances the fruits natural swe
etness" [04:24].
Correction: Change fruits to fruit's [05:33].
Explanation: The natural sweetness belongs to the fruit, requiring a possessive apostrophe before the s [05:33]. The host also notes the common error of misplacing apostrophes in plurals, often referred to as the "greengrocer's apostrophe" [06:15].
Mistake 4: Incorrect Two-Dot Punctuation (Line 4)
Context: "...tomatoes with milk dot dot they sound wrong..." [06:51].
Correction: Change the two dots to an
ellipsis consisting of three dots (...) [07:18].
Explanation: An ellipsis in English always requires exactly three dots to indicate a pause or build suspense [07:18].
Mistake 5: Missing Capital Letter at the Beginning of a Sentence (Final Line)
Context: "...next time someone criticizes..." [08:29].
Correction: Capitalize the word next to start the sentence properly [08:51].
Mistake 6: Incorrect Colon Usage (Final Line)
Context: "...next time someone criticizes your
weird snack colon remember that..." [08:29].
Correction: Replace the colon with a comma [09:31].
Explanation: Colons must follow an independent clause. Because "Next time someone criticizes your weird snack" is a dependent clause, a colon cannot be used to link it directly to the next clause [09:21].
Mistake 7: Missing Full Stop at the End of the Text (Final Line)
Context: "...best culinary secrets" [08:29].
Correction: Add a full stop at the very end of the sentenc
e [08:58].
Additional Resources
At the end of the lesson, the host invites viewers to leave a comment with their own weird food combinations using correct punctuation and offers a free downloadable PDF containing lesson notes, extra tips, and punctuation jokes via a link in the description [01:54], [10:06], [10:25].
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VqxJsw-z2Gg
There is just 1 mistake in this text. Advanced English learners will identify it.
English with Lucy · 50K vie
Viewer Discussion & Comments